Sunday 26 June 2016

June 26, 2016 sermon: Sometimes Silence Isn't Golden

He said to me, O mortal, eat what is offered to you; eat this scroll, and go, speak to the house of Israel. So I opened my mouth, and he gave me the scroll to eat. He said to me, Mortal, eat this scroll that I give you and fill your stomach with it. Then I ate it; and in my mouth it was as sweet as honey. He said to me: Mortal, go to the house of Israel and speak my very words to them.
(Ezekiel 3:1-4)

= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =

     It's not a biblical proverb, but it is a very old proverb: “silence is golden.” Apparently this proverb may go back to the time of ancient Egypt. Perhaps Pharaoh, dealing with the incessant demand of Moses to “let the people go,” looked at him and said, “Moses, silence is golden,” or whatever the ancient Egyptian version of the proverb was, in an attempt to shut him up. In English, the words “silence is golden” first appeared in a writing by the poet Thomas Carlyle. He actually translated the phrase from a work in German called Sartor Resartus in 1831. In that work, the words are put on the lips of a character who speaks at great length about the virtues of staying silent:

Silence is the element in which great things fashion themselves together; that at length they may emerge, full-formed and majestic, into the daylight of Life, which they are thenceforth to rule. ... Speech is too often ... the art ... of quite stifling and suspending Thought, so that there is none to conceal. Speech too is great, but not the greatest. As the Swiss Inscription says: Sprecfien ist silbern, Schweigen ist golden (Speech is silvern, Silence is golden); or as I might rather express it: Speech is of Time, Silence is of Eternity."

     Silence does have its virtues. Of that I have no doubt. Silence is sometimes – and perhaps even most often – how we encounter God most powerfully. But silence can also be a way of avoiding tough issues; of staying away from those things that make us squirm. Because of the M&S Service two weeks ago and last Sunday's Father's Day service led by the Men's Group, this is the first Sunday that I've preached since the horrible mass shooting in Orlando, Florida. On the morning that it happened, I had only heard that there had been a shooting in Orlando, and without any of the details I'm sorry to say that my first response was “another one” - a common reaction I admit to the regular cycle of mass shootings in the United States. At church that morning, Ruth Webster offered a prayer for the victims but it wasn't until I got home later in the day that I discovered the details of what had happened. And I wondered – what would I have done or said in church if I had known about it and been leading the service? Probably, I suspect, exactly what Ruth did so well: remember the victims in our prayers and then move on. After all, Orlando is a long way away, and this is Canada – such things don't happen here. But it kept pecking away at me. We should say something. This needs to be addressed in some way. This needs to be spoken about. And I was especially taken with the words of Katherine Clark, a member of the United States House of Representatives from Massachussetts, who refused to take part in a moment of silence on the House floor, and explained her decision this way: “a moment of silence is an empty gesture that accomplishes nothing.” She's right. And staying silent accomplishes even less, perhaps – or may even add to the problem by giving the impression that no one cares. In this case, silence isn't golden. We have to have something to say. The church has to have something to say. The people of God have to have something to say. If we can’t speak out against one of the most horrific acts of hatred ever against an obviously targeted group, then something’s seriously wrong. And then I thought about the Prophet Ezekiel.

     I love the Prophet Ezekiel’s equation of the word of God with honey. I think there’s an important comparison to be made there. Unfortunately, I think most people in the modern world don’t really understand what Ezekiel was saying. We tend to think of honey as simply a sweetener. Sometimes I put it on toast or bagels, or in a cup of tea. And because of that we sometimes interpret Ezekiel’s words to mean that the word of God is simply sweet and pleasant and unchallenging and shouldn’t disturb us too much. It should just make us happy and comfortable. It should be nothing more than a feel-good word. And, yes, Ezekiel does say that the scroll he was given (which would have been a part of the word of God) tasted as sweet as honey. But sweetness wasn’t the only thing that mattered about honey in the ancient world. That image of honey would have brought forth a lot of images in people’s minds in Ezekiel's day. In the ancient world there was something called “mad honey.” It was made by bees from certain types of plants and it would affect the brain and the central nervous system of those who ate it. So it wasn’t uncommon for ancient armies to put enticing looking chunks of mad honeycomb in the path of their enemies – who, after consuming them, would be virtually paralyzed and helpless. Mad honey was also used in small amounts by prophets who would use it essentially to get high, which would enhance their prophetic utterances. (Not that I’m accusing Ezekiel of that!) Setting mad honey aside, regular honey was commonly used as a medicine in the ancient world. It has anti-bacterial properties, so smearing honey on cuts and wounds is actually still a useful thing to do. Raw unprocessed honey was also a major source of nutrition for many people in the ancient world. It’s full of vitamins and minerals, and honeycomb back then was relatively easy to find. The other great thing about honey is that it literally doesn’t spoil. Not long ago archaeologists opened an ancient Egyptian tomb and found honey that was over three thousand years old – and was still edible! So honey had a lot of uses. When Ezekiel makes the connection between the word of God and honey, he’s not simply saying that the word of God is sweet and comforting. He’s saying that it’s challenging; it can defeat the forces arrayed against us; it can push us to speak the word of God; it can strengthen us and heal us; it is eternal and ever-lasting. This is honey and this is the word of God. This is what we need when hatred raises its ugly head.

     If my comments today are inspired by the Orlando shooting, I want to make sure that we don’t become complacent and think that hatred and violence and groups being targeted is just an “American thing.” In 2013 there were 186 hate crimes against the LGBT community recorded by police in Canada, and just in the news over the last few days there was a report of a pig’s head being left at the door of a mosque in Quebec City and of a Muslim woman wearing a hijab who was shopping with her four month old son in London only to suddenly and without provocation be spit upon and punched out by an angry white woman who apparently didn’t care much for Muslims. When people hate and they start to target others because of their hate then the powerful, inspiring, strengthening and eternal word of God needs to confront the haters. And all sorts of groups get targeted in our society. Muslims are called terrorists; gays are called perverts; blacks are carded by police; aboriginals are dismissed as drunks; the poor are blamed for being lazy; women are told they asked for it when they get sexually assaulted. And too often the church stays silent and does nothing except perhaps offer a few prayers for the victims. I’m a big believer in the power of prayer but I think we have to be a lot more outspoken when confronting hatred and when standing alongside those who find themselves targeted by haters. But too often Christians can find ways to avoid that responsibility and to simply stay silent at best because it's the easy thing to do or to encourage the hatred at worst because there are some who warp the teachings of Jesus to serve evil ends.

     It always astonishes me that there are Christians who seem to think that when Jesus said “love your neighbour,” he only meant the neighbours that you like and agree with and get along with. It never ceases to amaze me that there are Christians who seem to think that when Jesus said “love your enemies,” he must have been misquoted. It never ceases to amaze me that after everything Jesus taught about love, and after John wrote in his first letter that “God is love,” there are Christians who seem to believe that those teachings about love give them the right to hate those they disagree with. Jesus must sometimes weep bitter tears when he looks at his church and sees at least some of his people engaging in the most vile acts and speaking the most vicious and hate-filled words. There were preachers after the Orlando shooting who expressed the opinion that the only bad thing that happened was that the shooter didn’t finish the job he had started of mowing down gay people with a semi-automatic rifle. And the infamous Westboro Baptist Church brought their vile message of hatred to Orlando, as they picketed the funerals of some who had been killed, hoping to scream at grieving family members that their loved ones were hated by God and had gone to hell. (Thankfully, those families were shielded from this obnoxious group that shouldn't even be called a “church” by some who chose not to simply be silent.)

     Where does such hatred come from? How does such a warped understanding of the gospel take possession of people’s hearts? It surely comes from hearts that have hardened themselves to the truth of God’s word and to the reality of God’s love to the point at which, in an Orwellian sort of turn, hate becomes love; hate becomes what God is about.

     But it isn’t. God is love. Always. That is not conditional. God is love. And we are to love. Jesus taught love. That was not conditional, either. And real love isn’t easy. We need all of the strength and help of the honey-like word of God that Ezekiel wrote of to enable us to truly love and to encourage us to speak out. After the Orlando shooting, the National Council of Canadian Muslims released a statement that said in part “As Canadians we stand united against violence and discrimination against any human being.” And the Reverend Rob Oliphant, a United Church minister and also a Member of Parliament, said that “Hate has to be met with love.” And the point is that love cannot be silent. Love must be spoken; love must be expressed; love must be acted upon. When we – any of us – see or hear hatred being directed at people we – individually or as a community – need to speak up and speak out, because we we who believe in a God who is love must find ways to actively love those who are the targets of hatred, discrimination, oppression, fear-mongering and violence. And if there are those who don’t like us doing that and who prefer to wallow in either hate or indifference toward the hatred we sometimes see around us – well, that’s tough! We must loosen our tongues and be heard.


     In 1382, John Wyclif translated the Bible into the English of the day for the very first time. His translation of Revelation 8 included the words, “silence is maad in heuen” – meaning in modern English: silence is made in heaven. Perhaps, but this isn't heaven, and the things that happen in the world around us aren't always heavenly. And when those unheavenly things happen, the people of God need to speak up and to speak out and to be heard loud and clear, lest our own faith be drowned out by the voices of hatred that so often surround us.

No comments:

Post a Comment